Back to Blog
3 min read

How We Design WitBlox Boards With Embedr

WitBlox's lead hardware engineer on moving new PCB designs to Embedr: two product designs laid out without changes after review, respins down from two-to-four per board to one on average, and idea to pre-production in about two weeks.

PM

Prathamesh Mundhe

Lead Hardware EngineerWitBlox

The WitBlox Accelero TX and RX Blox: a blue transmitter board with an accelerometer module and an ESP-12E, and a purple receiver board with four outputs
The WitBlox Accelero TX and RX Blox: a blue transmitter board with an accelerometer module and an ESP-12E, and a purple receiver board with four outputs

I lead hardware engineering at WitBlox. We make Blox: small electronic blocks that plug into each other, so a student can join a power Blox, a sensor Blox and an output Blox and have a working circuit. Every new Blox is a new PCB, and it has to fit the ones we already sell.

We have used Embedr on a few products that are now in production. Two of them are the Accelero TX/RX Blox and the Clap Sensor. This post is about how those two product designs were made and what has changed for us since.

What we gave Embedr

For both designs I gave Embedr two things.

  • Our existing Blox designs. A new Blox has to connect to the rest of the range, so the headers must sit in the same places. Embedr read the existing designs to learn where they go.
  • Datasheets for the parts we had already picked. We source from a vendor we know, and we chose the components ourselves. We did not use Embedr for component selection on these designs.

What Embedr did

From those inputs, Embedr did the PCB work:

  1. It made the footprints from the datasheets.
  2. It made the 3D models as STEP files, also from scratch.
  3. It laid out the boards for both designs. That is three boards in all, each with two layers.
  4. It ran the design checks on the finished layouts and validated them.

I reviewed both designs afterwards. I did not have to change anything.

The Clap Sensor, Accelero TX and Accelero RX boards side by side at the same scale, showing copper, pads and silkscreen
The layouts of the Clap Sensor and the two Accelero boards, at the same scale.
The Accelero transmitter and receiver boards with labels for the mode switch, threshold knob, accelerometer module, ESP-12E module, Blox edge headers and the four receiver outputs
The Accelero TX/RX Blox as sold. The edge headers are in the same positions as on our other Blox.
Top and bottom of the Clap Sensor board: the microphone footprint, a trimmer and two rows of Blox header pads on top, and the surface-mount parts on the bottom
The Clap Sensor layout, top and bottom.

Fewer respins

Before Embedr, we designed our boards in Proteus, and a board took two to four respins depending on how complex it was. Some of those respins had good reasons: the scope changed, or we wanted to bring the cost down. Others were plain mistakes, such as a footprint that was the wrong size, or one that was mirrored.

We now average one respin per design. Embedr also helps in the research and scope phase, so it is easier to get the scope clear before layout starts. And we have not had a wrong-size or mirrored footprint since we started using it.

From months to weeks

Getting a board from idea to just before production used to take us one to three months, depending on the project. It is now about two weeks, and most of that is waiting for the boards to come back from fabrication. The PCB design itself takes a day or two.

Two bar charts. Respins per board: two to four before, one on average now. Idea to pre-production: one to three months before, about two weeks now.
Our estimates from our own projects, before and after we moved PCB design to Embedr. They are not a formal benchmark.
BeforeNow
Respins per board2 to 41 on average
Idea to pre-production1 to 3 monthsAbout 2 weeks: 1 to 2 days of design, the rest is fab time
Wrong-size or mirrored footprintsBehind some of our respinsNone so far

Where we are now

We have adopted Embedr for PCB design, and we use it for every new PCB project as it comes in. The Accelero TX/RX Blox and the Clap Sensor are two of the products made this way. Both are in production and listed on the WitBlox store.

PM

Prathamesh Mundhe

Lead Hardware EngineerWitBlox

Build with Embedr

Take your next hardware project from idea to working system.

Download Embedr